3 Comments
User's avatar
Michael Doane's avatar

Hey Joe! I feel like I could start a channel just replying to your content but I can’t pump out videos fast enough lol. (I swear my other response is around the corner)

But, I just had to jump in here. And I’m not here to challenge your ethics or moral argument, that’s can be for another day. I really just want to highlight that it seems you are changing the topic pretty hard on atheist dude.

At the end of the day, you and him agree that we shouldn’t let people die. He may not have a reason per se, (though he does) that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t engage in gun violence.

Let’s say me and you were hanging out, you know my worldview. And we someone raping a woman and I jumped in to help. Would you question me like β€œwell why bother helping”? I mean it could be a good and fair question to ask later. But we both would agree it’s good I stopped it

So when he is trying to discuss gun violence, discuss it. Don’t move to a philosophy conversation. Otherwise it seems like you just aren’t willing to engage in politics with people who aren’t religious in some capacity. Would love your thoughts though

Expand full comment
Joe Petruzzi βœοΈπŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ's avatar

Hey Michael, maybe I wasn’t precise in the intro. Me and him don’t agree on how to stop gun violence.

I believe in the right to protect ourselves, I deny a tyrannical regime stripping its citizens of defense. Atheist dude does not. But why?different worldviews. With a Biblical worldview, it’s clear that we should defend ourselves, and the human heart is desperately wicked.

But on the atheist worldview, a lot of these things get pushed to the state, so people conjure up ways to stop violence even if it strips away rights.

It would be like you and me seeing a women getting raped, and I went to save her, and then you put a blanket over her so β€œmen aren’t tempted.” We both hate rape, but we solve it differently. My way affirms the man is evil, your way affirms that the man would do less of it if he β€œjust wasn’t tempted” (this is hypothetical obviously).

I wasn’t deflecting, I was getting to the heart of the matter

Expand full comment
Michael Doane's avatar

Checking again I think you were clear! That’s what I get for listening while getting ready for work. I missed some details.

Expand full comment